Man Utd's summer transfer window - graded

If you were to rewind to the eve of the Premier League season, there was a genuine sense of optimism among Manchester United fans.

Four games and one month on, that feeling has somewhat subsided. The Red Devils have won just two matches - both in unconvincing fashion at home to teams tipped to battle relegation - while they were beaten by north London duo Tottenham Hotspur and Arsenal.

What looked like a promising transfer window a few weeks ago now appears to be an underwhelming one due to this slow start to the new campaign.

Was it really that lacklustre, though? Here's how 90min graded their transactions this summer.

2023/24 Man Utd arrivals

Mason Mount - B+

Erik ten Hag's decision to use Mason Mount and Bruno Fernandes as advanced midfielders in front of a lone six in Casemiro has been strange, with the duo often leaving the Brazilian high and dry.

The former Chelsea star was sidelined with injury following the second weekend of the new season and Man Utd have looked far more comfortable with Christian Eriksen coming back into the fold, fulfilling the need to sit a little deeper and give Casemiro a helping hand.

If Mount continues to roam free upon his return, then Man Utd will continue to cede midfield battles and his transfer could quickly be deemed a failure. But at £55m and so, so much of his Old Trafford career remaining, it remains a punt that was worth taking. Don't listen to the social media trolls.

Andre Onana - A

Man Utd's need to bring in a new goalkeeper - one comfortable with the ball at their feet - was paramount this summer, even if it wasn't in their initial plans (we'll come to that later).

In Andre Onana, they have recruited one of the world's best in that department, a fearless maverick that will not be spooked when on the ball or asked to play the Ten Hag way like David de Gea was.

A huge upgrade in their weakest area. Good job, Man Utd.

Rasmus Hojlund - C+

Man Utd have been crying out for a striker that carries out actual striker duties for quite some time.

Edinson Cavani was a neat stop-gap back in 2020/21, but his run up front was short-lived. Marcus Rashford is clearly a wide player. Cristiano Ronaldo cared about only one thing, and that was Cristiano Ronaldo. Anthony Martial, thanks for your amazing 2019/20 campaign, but it's time to go.

Whether Man Utd were right to dump an initial £64m on a slightly unproven 20-year-old can be debated (or, in my eyes, labelled as quite a daft thing to do). But he is at least a classic number nine and fulfils his required duties well, with ample room to grow at his young age. Every cloud.

Altay Bayinidir - C+

A proven backup goalkeeper signed on the cheap. We don't need to turn this into a long essay. Decent business, no more and no less.

Sergio Reguilon - B-

With injuries to senior left-backs Luke Shaw and Tyrell Malacia threatening to derail the beginning of Man Utd's season (you know, beyond this indifferent start), the Red Devils turned to the market to bring in a short-term replacement.

Sergio Reguilon is hardly the finest player or the best defender, but he's a Premier League-level left-back that has long been on the club's radar. For someone that'll be relegated to third-choice in the coming months, that's a nice little pick-up.

Maybe they should heed some caution that Tottenham were so happy to shift him to a rival, however.

Jonny Evans - B-

Listen, Man Utd fans. It's fine that a senior pro like Jonny Evans is your fifth-choice centre-back.

How many teams get through three or four of them before turning to number five? It's just rotten luck that the veteran defender took to the pitch in Sunday's loss at Arsenal.

Against most teams, Evans should be able to hold his own and it's unlikely he'll even feature much more this season. Part of the reason he even returned to Old Trafford was to provide an experienced head and POV. That remains the case. Don't lose your marbles.

Sofyan Amrabat - A

While the signing of Mount looks questionable given how he's been utilised so far, Sofyan Amrabat's arrival provides Man Utd with the perfect tonic to treat that woe.

A physical and technical presence that is capable of playing with Casemiro as well as instead of, the Moroccan should help provide the midfield steeliness that Ten Hag's side have lacked so far this term.

Factor in that Man Utd are only paying £8.5m for a season-long loan and retain a £17.1m clause to sign him permanently from Fiorentina next summer and this is a golden transfer, perhaps their best bit of business.

READ THE LATEST MAN UTD NEWS, TRANSFER RUMOURS & GOSSIP

2023/24 Man Utd departures

David de Gea - A

Man Utd's treatment of a club legend like De Gea at the end of his Old Trafford career was shocking, let's not get it twisted.

It seemed for all the world that the two parties would agree on a new contract beyond the expiry of his previous one at the end of June. But the club walked back on their prior agreement and he eventually walked away for free.

The timing and sudden change of heart was immoral, but it's a decision that should have been determined months in advance.

At the time of his exit, De Gea was the weakest player in Man Utd's starting lineup, a consistent source of errors and a liability in possession. He needed replacing. At least the Red Devils saw sense to cut the cord in the end regardless of how cruel that conclusion came to be. That De Gea is still without a club further proves his low standing in the modern game.

Alex Telles - B

Alex Telles was signed in 2020 as an alternative to Reguilon. He has now been replaced in the Man Utd squad by the Spaniard three years on with neither of their stock particular high.

It was paramount for Man Utd to shift their deadwood anyway anyhow. Thank you, Al Nassr, for the £4m. Have a good day.

Anthony Elanga - C+

Time will tell whether Man Utd were right to keep Antony and Jadon Sancho but move on Anthony Elanga.

The Swede's game is typically rudimentary for a winger, but he has quickly become a fan favourite at Nottingham Forest - a team that plays to his strengths.

If Elanga's form continues, there will be plenty of discussions about why he was allowed to leave Old Trafford.

Fred - A-

Ah, a rather more luxurious version of the Telles conversation.

Hello, Fenerbahce? You're willing to pay nearly £13m for a player we're desperately trying to shift? I don't know, we'll have to think about it...ok that's enough thinking you have a deal.

This argument helps a lot more if you ignore that Fred was one of Man Utd's most expensive signings of all time when he joined back in 2018.

Dean Henderson - A-

Whether Man Utd were too hasty to end their experiment with Dean Henderson as their starting goalkeeper is a question for another day, but to get £20m for a backup goalkeeper is impressive business. Even if we're sure that Deano will smash it down at Selhurst Park.

Eric Bailly - C+

This was very nearly in the Telles/Fred bracket, but...you couldn't even get a fee for Eric Bailly? Seriously, Man Utd? He was at least playing Champions League football last season, for crying out loud.

LISTEN NOW TO 90MIN'S TALKING TRANSFERS PODCAST

On this edition of Talking Transfers, part of the 90min podcast network, Scott Saunders is joined by Graeme Bailey to discuss Al Ittihad's attempts to sign Mohamed Salah, Jadon Sancho's Man Utd future, the players that could still leave the Premier League and more! If you can't see this embed, click here to listen to the podcast!