Man Utd 4-2 Everton Conti Cup: Player ratings as win not enough for Red Devils

Jamie Spencer
Marc Skinner's Manchester United were victorious in the Continental Cup
Marc Skinner's Manchester United were victorious in the Continental Cup / Harriet Lander/GettyImages

From Leigh Sports Village – Manchester United cruised to a 4-2 victory Everton in the Continental Cup group stage but will not progress to the knockout rounds, despite still having another game left to play later this month, due to results elsewhere on Wednesday night.

Vilde Boe Risa scored two early goals in a statement performance to stake her claim for a more regular place, with Rachel Williams and Jade Moore also on the score-sheet in an action-packed first half played at an electric tempo on an icy night in Greater Manchester.

Jess Park pulled one back for Everton when it was 3-0, but by then it was always going to be an uphill battle for the Toffees. Karen Holmgaard got another consolation in stoppage time.

It was a heavily rotated United side only days ahead of a crucial Manchester derby. But as they so often have done at home in the WSL this season, the hosts made a flying start to the game and had the lead with only a minute on the clock as Boe Risa nodded in Ona Batlle’s clip into the box.

Not much longer had passed when Williams followed up her Old Trafford goal at the weekend with a close-range finish. Everton failed to deal with a cross and the veteran striker stabbed the ball high into the net as Lucia Garcia turned it back into the middle.

United’s third goal from Boe Risa in only the 19th minute was the result of a clinical break but more poor Everton defending. Lucy Staniforth was involved in releasing Martha Thomas down the right wing, with Boe Risa beating Everton goalkeeper Courtney Brosnan to the ball in the box.

But the hosts will have been disappointed to have then conceded, with stand-in goalkeeper Sophie Baggaley misjudging the flight of a through ball, allowing Jess Park to take it round her. United did immediately respond, though, as Moore bundled in from close range – all inside half an hour.

Everton made a much more positive start to the second half and Park struck the bar, while half-time substitute Nicoline Sorensen also forced Baggaley into a low save at the near post. Substitutions definitely made a difference and Brian Sorensen must have been ruing the opening 20 minutes that took the game away from his team so quickly at the start.

Brosnan just about did enough to deny the hosts a fifth when Thomas went chasing after a through ball. It broke to the United striker with the goal potentially gaping, but the chance had gone by the time she managed to sort her feet.

Everton grabbed a second consolation at the death when Katja Snoeijs lifted the ball to the far corner and Holmgaard bundled the ball over the line.

Man Utd player ratings (4-3-3)

GK: Sophie Baggaley - 6/10 - Not the most convincing performance. At fault for the Everton goal, which will disappoint her on a rare chance to play. Made saves in the second half.

RB: Ona Batlle (c) - 8/10 - Captained the side again in this competition and picked up where she left off at the weekend with another excellent attacking performance until she was rested.

CB: Aissatou Tounkara - 6/10 - Still finding her feet in English football after so few chances since joining United. Good and bad in parts here.

CB: Millie Turner - 7/10 - Solid until being rested at half-time. Everton didn't much threaten when she was on the pitch.

LB: Maria Thorisdottir - 6/10 - Showed her versatility after previously impressing at left-back against Everton in the league.

CM: Lucy Staniforth - 7/10 - Gave a big performance in the first half to effectively win the game in the first 20 minutes.

CM: Jade Moore - 7/10 - In the team primarily to shield the back four but got forward to score.

CM: Vilde Boe Risa - 8/10 - Needed to make a statement if she wants to force her way into the WSL starting XI and went about it the right way with two early goals. Faded later on.

RF: Martha Thomas - 7/10 - Looked keen to impress with energy down the right. Assisted the third.

ST: Rachel Williams - 7/10 - Scored for the second game in a row and worked hard in both boxes.

LF: Lucia Garcia - 7/10 - Will take confidence from an early assist on her first start since October. Continued to stretch the game in the second half when United withdrew a little.


SUB: Katie Zelem (46' for Moore) - 6/10

SUB: Maya Le Tissier (46' for Turner) - 6/10

SUB: Hannah Blundell (46' for Batlle) - 6/10

SUB: Ella Toone (79' for Thomas) - 6/10

SUB: Leah Galton (85' for Williams) - N/A


Marc Skinner - 7/10 - Pleased to see his team blow another opponent away in the first half with a high tempo performance. Surprising to see Zelem and Le Tissier come on so early with a comfortable lead by then and a big game also coming up on Sunday.

Everton player ratings (4-3-3)

GK: Courtney Brosnan - 4/10 - Will be disappointed with several of the goals that went in.

RB: Leonie Maier - 4/10 - Not a great performance and off at half-time.

CB: Nathalie Bjorn - 5/10 - Played on the right of a back three in the second half and did well to keep Garcia and Galton from doing more damage. But the game was gone.

CB: Rikke Sevecke - 4/10 - Given the run around by Williams and Thomas in a first half that quickly defined the game.

LB: Gabby George - 4/10 - Caught too far forward when United scored their second and third. Transitioned to a more comfortable wing-back role later on.

CM: Aurora Galli - 5/10 - Off the pace in the first half but improved after the break.

CM: Karen Holmgaard - 5/10 - Wasn't a match for Boe Risa, Staniforth or Moore to begin with. Dropped into a more resilient back-line in the second half and scored in stoppage time.

CM: Hanna Bennison - 5/10 - Became more involved after half-time but also had to walk a tightrope after taking a cynical booking.

RF: Aggie Beever-Jones - 5/10 - Didn't really threaten as she is capable of.

ST: Gio - 4/10 - Withdrawn inside half an hour. Unclear if it was injury related.

LF: Jess Park - 7/10 - Everton's biggest threat by some distance. Made the most of a Baggaley error to pull one back in the first half and hit the bar after half-time.


SUB: Katja Snoeijs (29' for Gio) - 6/10

SUB: Nicoline Sorensen (46' for Beever-Jones) - 6/10

SUB: Lucy Graham (46' for Maier) - 6/10

SUB: Izzy Christiansen (62' for Bennison) - 6/10


Brian Sorensen - 6/10 - The second time this season he has seen his team picked apart by Manchester United, despite much closer games against Manchester City and Arsenal recently. Substitutes definitely made a difference to the performance but it was too late by then.

Player of the match - Vilde Boe Risa (Man Utd)

For more from Jamie Spencer, follow him on Twitter!